The Best Wedding Cake Bakeries in Payson, AZ

The Best Wedding Cake Bakeries in Payson, AZ

How do we sort results, including Sponsored Ads and personalized results?


51 Wedding Cakes & Desserts in Payson, AZ

Quick responder
Kendra's Country Bakery 

5.0

Payson, AZ

    Welcome to Kendra's Country Bakery where every cake is customized to suit your needs! My initial inspiration comes from my grandparents. Although I was young when they passed, I can still remember my grandfather's signature red buttercream rose hidden on every cake. In the beginning, while raising my family with my husband, I was so excited to get into the baking world and learn what it had to offer. I had been baking for years so I decided to do what I love and share it with others!

    Awarded Best of Zola
    We absolutely loved working with Kendra’s Country Bakery! Kendra and Maureen, the sweetest mother-daughter duo, brought such a warm, small-town, family feel to the entire process. My husband and I ordered a two-tier cake along with an assortment of cupcakes, and our guests could not stop raving about the incredible variety of flavors and how delicious everything was, we had nothing left by the end of the night because everyone kept going back for seconds! Kendra and Maureen completely exceeded my expectations with the cake design. They effortlessly incorporated our flowers and our custom cake topper featuring our huskies, it was beautiful and so personal. They were communicative, easy to work with, and coordinated seamlessly with my venue and wedding coordinator. They even set up the dessert table at the reception, and it looked stunning. Their attention to detail and professionalism truly made this part of our wedding day perfect. I couldn’t recommend them more!
    Tracy L., 7 months ago
    Quick responder
    A. Cakes Bakery 

    5.0

    • Starts at $800
    • Serves Payson, AZ

    I grew up in Omaha, Nebraska surrounded by weddings and events. My family owns an event venue there still. I took a detour and played professional golf for a number of years before A. Cakes was born in 2021. It was only fitting that I come full circle and work back in the wedding industry where my heart truly lies. I am in love with the process of learning, practicing and executing new and fun techniques on my clients’ cakes. More than that, creating a cake for someone’s special day gives me the most warm feeling. It’s truly why I do what I do.

    Awarded Best of Zola
    We couldn’t be happier with our wedding cake! It was the most beautiful vintage-style cake, and Armana perfectly captured the design exactly as I had envisioned. From the custom sample cakes to the final product, every detail was spot on. The red velvet cake was absolutely delicious, and all of our guests couldn’t stop raving about it. We’re beyond thrilled with how everything turned out. Thank you for making our day extra special!
    Amy R., a year ago
    Piece of Cake 

    4.7

    • Starts at $400
    • Serves Payson, AZ

    We have an awesome job! Seriously. Being in the business of making wedding cakes is amazing. Not only do we get to do for a living what millions of people do for a hobby, but we are constantly meeting couples that are in the midst of the happiest time of their lives. So, we love what we do and other people love what we do. Are you picking up what I'm putting down? Yep, it's good to be POC. Even cooler is the fact that not only do our customers love what we do, but the very best wedding reception sites in the valley trust us enough to stake their reputations on our work by including our cakes in their all inclusive wedding packages.

    The cake was amazing! The flavors were vanilla, red velvet & cinnamon churro. People raved about it. From the style to the detail to the delivery to the eating! Loved it and can’t wait to order our 1 year top. We barely had any left to take home! So grateful to you all for making our day that much sweeter!
    Stephanie Z., a year ago
    GemHidden gem
    Goodies by Max 

    5.0

    • Starts at $120
    • Serves Payson, AZ

    Goodies by Max is a registered cottage home-based bakery in Desert Ridge, Phoenix AZ, specializes in custom decorated sugar cookies and cookie classes for private or company events! We love creating a custom set for each and every one of our customers for their special day.

    Awarded Best of Zola
    I won't be able to convey my sentiment of gratitude for meeting Lioni & Max. I am on the Activities Team at an Assisted Living Facility, specifically Memory Care. I contacted Goodies by Max for a Christmas Cookie decorating class. First off, Lioni is always available for any questions or concerns you may have. She is so very professional - leading from her heart. Dean is great... he helped me set up the tables and chairs for the event and stayed and assisted Lioni with the class. The class was AWESOME. I know it probably wasn't like the classes they were used to facilitating.... but they were a perfect fit. The success of the class was because of every little thing they did or didn't do because of the clientele at the table... from precutting the icing bags to explaining the activity to each person individually as folks came out to the table. It was a very heartwarming activity for everyone involved. Lioni and Max are the REAL DEAL. They are VERY responsive, streamlined, punctual, creative and most importantly for me, they have huge hearts and are able to meet the client where they sit and adjust accordingly. They were open for hugs and chatting about anything. They weren't in a hurry so noone felt rushed. I wish I could give GOODIES BY MAX a thousand stars! I recommend the team of Lioni and Dean for ANY event for which you are thinking. A group of folks gathered around a table creating yummy art will always be a good thing!
    Destiny L., 2 months ago
    Quick responder
    Sugar Mamas Bakery AZ 

    5.0

    • Starts at $210
    • Serves Payson, AZ

    Welcome to Sugar Mamas Bakery AZ, where sweetness meets creativity! We are a small, licensed and insured-cottage bakery dedicated to crafting custom cakes and delightful mini desserts that make every occasion special. Our passion for baking is evident in each unique creation, from stunning wedding cakes to fun birthday treats. In addition to our delicious offerings, we also provide cake bar rentals, perfect for adding a touch of whimsy to your event. Let us help you celebrate life's sweetest moments with our delectable and beautifully presented desserts. At Sugar Mamas, we believe that every bite should be a memorable experience!

    Sugar Mamas Bakery AZ was a pleasure to work with for our wedding. Their communication style was open and honest, which made the process of ordering our wedding cake and desserts stress-free. The quality of their work was absolutely beautiful, and the cakes and desserts were delicious - worth every penny. They were able to stay within our budget, which took a lot of pressure off during the planning process. The final products were not only gorgeous, but also incredibly tasty. We would highly recommend Sugar Mamas Bakery AZ to any couple looking for exceptional wedding cakes and desserts.
    Anita, 2 months ago
    Quick responder
    Sugar Cookies by Suzanne 

    5.0

    • Starts at $250
    • Serves Payson, AZ

    Sugar Cookies by Suzanne is a dessert business that makes delicious sugar cookies for weddings in Phoenix, Arizona. This sweet company is owned and run by Suzanne Kocsis, whose aim is to share her grandmother's scrumptious treats with you and your guests. These one-of-a-kind delights would make a lovely addition to a dessert table or even as a favor for your loved ones to take home. She also has the ability to add your favorite photos to the cookies for more personalized option . Reach out to Sugar Cookies by Suzanne to find out more.

    Awarded Best of Zola
    From the moment I reached out to Suzanne, her friendly and professional communication style put me at ease. She was so helpful in walking me through all the options for beautiful, detailed cookie designs that would fit the theme of our wedding. On the day of, Suzanne's cookies were a huge hit - everyone loved how delicious and beautiful they were. In fact, I've ordered Suzanne's cookies for so many other special events like our engagement party, bridal shower, graduation, and even baby's baptism. Her cookies are always a crowd-pleaser that exceed expectations. Guests at all of my events always look for Suzanne's beautiful cookies at the table. I highly recommend Sugar Cookies by Suzanne for any wedding or event! They really are amazing!
    CharlyA, 6 months ago
    Quick responder
    Bomb Confections 

    5.0

    • Starts at $1
    • Serves Payson, AZ

    Welcome to my world of delectable creations! I'm Sandi, the passionate artisan behind these unique flavor-infused confections. For years, l've been crafting these delectables as a labor of love for family and friends during the holiday season. Their enthusiastic responses, filled with remarks like "You should be selling these" and "Oh my gosh, you made these?" fueled my culinary curiosity.

    Awarded Best of Zola
    We had the best experience working with Sandi at Bomb Confections for our wedding! The chocolates were absolutely delicious and they arrived perfectly for our wedding. They were a big hit with everyone! Sandi is one of the kindest, most generous and hard working people we’ve had the opportunity to know. We highly recommend Bomb Confections for your wedding or next event! Or even if you just want to some delicious, high quality chocolates and treats!
    Dara Z., 2 years ago
    Quick responder
    Lari Bakery 

    5.0

    • Starts at $500
    • Serves Payson, AZ

    Welcome to Lari Bakery, your premier destination for European-style desserts in Phoenix, AZ. As a licensed home bakery, we specialize in creating exquisite cakes and pastries that blend traditional European techniques with modern flair. Each creation is a masterpiece, meticulously crafted to not only satisfy your taste buds but also delight your senses with its artful presentation.

    Awarded Best of Zola
    Lari Bakery was an absolute dream to work with for our wedding! Their communication was amazing - they answered any questions we had immediately and were so helpful throughout the entire process. The quality of their work was exceptional - our wedding cake was not only absolutely beautiful, but also delicious. Lari truly brought our vision to reality and created our dream wedding cake. It was a work of art that tasted amazing. We don't think you'll find a better bakery for your wedding - don't think twice about booking Lari Bakery!
    Marissa S., a year ago
    Silver Rose Bakery 

    5.0

    • Serves Payson, AZ

    Our goal here at Silver Rose Bakery is to create a cake or dessert display that is both beautiful in flavor and visual. We also want to make sure it represents you as a couple which is why we offer unique cake tasting experiences that allow you to create your own combinations. If you want a peanut butter & jelly cake at your wedding we won't stop you! Let's get together and chat about how we can make your day a little bit sweeter!

    Silver Rose Bakery was an absolute pleasure to work with for our wedding desserts. Their communication throughout the planning process was quick, thorough, and incredibly organized, which put us at ease. On the day of, their setup was beautiful, with an elegant display of cake pops, a stunning wedding cake, parfaits, and an assortment of delicious cheesecakes. Every single dessert was devoured by our guests, as the quality and flavor was impeccable. We cannot recommend Silver Rose Bakery enough - they truly helped make our special day even sweeter!
    Jenni M., a year ago
    Summer Sweets Bakery 

    5.0

    • Starts at $1,000
    • Serves Payson, AZ
    • Offer

    I was born and raised in a small town in the Philippines. I lived in California for 14 years and before moving to Arizona, I met my husband and my children (our lovely dogs). I started baking as far back as a little girl, with a simple interest in creating tasty treats for my family and I. Then I moved on to baking from scratch and began to appreciate the joy in producing and assembling each piece of the puzzle. Baking from scratch allows you to select not only the highest quality ingredients but it also creates a deeper connection between the baker and the food. As often happens, interest turned into a hobby, hobby turned into an obsession.

    Awarded Best of Zola
    So amazing in every way! Cake was beautiful and delicious and it was so easy to connect for planning, etc! Absolutely delicious and literally exactly what I had pictured in my mind!
    Callie H., 4 years ago
    Quick responder
    Graceful Cake Creations 

    5.0

    • Starts at $450
    • Serves Payson, AZ

    Graceful Cake Creations is an award winning small boutique bakery that makes exquisite custom cakes that taste as good as they look. We specialize in buttercream iced Wedding Cakes and Special Event Cakes. Our goal is to work with you in creating a design to express your taste, personality, style, and theme. From classic elegance to simple or contemporary we strive to ensure that every detail is just as you have envisioned it.

    Grace is professional with decades of experience. She created the cake of a my dreams that looked just like my inspo pics and was a joy to work with. We were able to pick multiple flavors, which were all delicious. Our guests raved about the different flavors and we enjoyed hearing their excitement about different flavors.
    Rosemary L., 3 months ago
    Quick responder
    Bahama Buck's 

    5.0

    • Starts at $504
    • Serves Payson, AZ

    We specialize in premium shaved ice and frozen treats served from our Sno Mobile. With vibrant flavors, customizable toppings, and a fun, interactive experience, Bahama Buck’s adds a refreshing and unforgettable twist your guests will love. From elegant outdoor weddings to laid-back beachy vibes, we help make your celebration extra cool.

    Having the Bahama Buck’s Sno Mobile at our wedding on 10/25 was a total crowd-pleaser! Guests of all ages were excited, the flavors were incredible, and the team was organized and friendly from start to finish. It brought such a fun, relaxed vibe to our wedding and made the night even more memorable. We’re still getting compliments about it!
    Nicole R., 2 months ago
    TrendlineTrending
    Sweet Buckets 

    5.0

    • Starts at $300
    • Serves Payson, AZ for additional fees

    We began as a concession company providing cotton candy at sporting events. In the fall of 2021, we extended our brand by starting our own manufacturing plant. Sweet Buckets was born as an option for customers and businesses to purchase Cotton Candy and Gourmet popcorns direct from our company.

    Awarded Best of Zola
    We had our wedding reception at a brewery and wanted some easy to eat sweet and salty snacks. These popcorn flavors were delicious, they sent us flavors to try before we decided. We chose 4 flavors and they shipped them right to our house. The popcorn buckets had our cute custom labels which they designed for us and looked PERFECT! We had tons of compliments on the popcorn. We ordered plenty and people were grabbing them to take home at the end of the night. A perfect snack after a few beers. Theu were very fast with the samples and the order too!
    Lyndsey C., 2 years ago
    Quick responder
    The Sweet Co. 

    5.0

    • Starts at $480
    • Serves Payson, AZ for additional fees

    At The Sweet Co., we believe every event deserves a touch of magic and a little extra sweetness. Founded with a passion for creating unforgettable dessert experiences, we specialize in elegant, interactive catering that transforms ordinary moments into extraordinary memories. From our famous Walking Cannoli Bar to our indulgent chocolate-covered strawberry cups, açaí bowls, and signature Crepes on a Stick, every detail is crafted to impress. Whether you’re planning an intimate celebration or a luxury wedding, our mission is simple: to delight your guests and make your event as beautiful and delicious as it is memorable.

    Awarded Best of Zola
    We are so grateful to have found you. On our little Sicily trip we had some amazing canolis and we are glad we were able to share them with our wedding guest as well.. So crunchy and delicious!
    Yeny L., 6 months ago
    BakerBitesCo 

    5.0

    • Starts at $200
    • Serves Payson, AZ for additional fees

    Ready to impress your guests with our unique tasty treat? BakerBitesCo offers single serve fudge bites with customized labels to fit your perfect day. Wedding favors, bridesmaids gifts, wedding party gifts, etc. these can be used in any way to fit your needs. WHY YOU'LL LOVE US -We offer delicious unique seasonal flavors -We ship anywhere in the US -We can send a sampler box so you can taste all our flavors and pick your favorites. -Budget friendly at only $2/piece -Prepackaged, making our dessert ideal during COVID -We give a meal to a hungry child with every order We can't wait to make your day even more spectacular!

    Best fudge I’ve ever had and the flavor varieties are amazing! I love that I can customize them for any occasion!
    Linda, 5 years ago
    GemHidden gem
    Ashley's Cakeshop 

    5.0

    • Starts at $96
    • Serves Payson, AZ

    Ashley's Cakeshop offers wedding cake services in Phoenix, AZ. Owner Ashley Cuellar goes above and beyond to create a delicious and beautiful cake for your special day. She can design cakes in various themes and styles, so you know you are getting something that perfectly fits your unique vision. Ashley would be honored to add an extra element of sweetness to your magical day. Before the big day, she can organize a tasting session so you can choose the perfect cake for you. She can also take care of delivery and setup, so all you have to worry about is spending quality time with the people you love.

    I'm so glad to have a found such a talented, local cake artist to support. Since initially finding her through a random search on Instagram, I have commissioned Ashley Cuellar several times over the years for my family's special moments, birthdays & even my wedding. Each time, Ashley delivered with excellence helping me to come up with a cake design based on my inspiration and delivering a delicious final product. I always recommend Ashley's Cake Shop to my friends and family when they are looking to make an occasion extra special!
    Lissie F., a year ago

    About wedding cakes & desserts in Payson, AZ

    What other Payson vendors will I need?

    What other cakes and desserts are nearby?

    What other wedding services are nearby?